Main navigation
- Graduate Students
- Faculty & Staff
- General requirements
- Preparation of a thesis
- Initial Thesis Submission
- Thesis examiners
- Evaluation of written thesis
- Thesis examination failures
- Doctoral oral defence
- Final Thesis Submission
- Thesis Writing and Support Resources
- Letters of Completion/PGWP
Evaluation of a Written Thesis
Examiners are asked to evaluate the thesis in myThesis, according to the criteria in the respective thesis examiner report for a Master's or Doctoral thesis. For an example of the criteria, please see the forms: see: Master's Examiner report form ; Doctoral Examiner report form (note these forms are now integrated in myThesis).
Examiners provide an overall judgment of 'passed' or ‘not passed’, in addition to a written report. For Master's students, this evaluation determines whether or not the thesis is ready for final submission, even if minor changes are recommended. For Doctoral candidates, this evaluation determines whether or not the candidate is ready to proceed to the oral defence.
If the thesis meets the general criteria for the degree sought, as well as those listed on the examiner's report form it should be evaluated as 'Passed', even if some changes are recommended.
If the overall judgement is 'Passed', examiners are asked to provide:
- A report that includes any recommendations for minor revisions to the thesis (i.e., stylistic or editorial changes that can be completed in three weeks or less).
- For doctoral theses, External Examiners who will not be at the oral defence must also provide a list of questions to be asked of the candidate at the oral defence.
An evaluation of 'Not Passed' should be given if:
- the need for a new study, experimentation, or significant additional research or reformulation.
- the need to address major problems with the presentation of the work. Stylistic or editorial changes are not normally considered to be major revisions, but if the quality of the presentation is so poor that extensive rewriting is required, the thesis should not be passed.
- At least one of the Criteria for the Evaluation of the Thesis (see Master's Examiner report form ; Doctoral Examiner report form ) is judged as unsatisfactory.
Examiners are asked to identify required changes clearly in their reports. The supervisor or another designated person will ensure that the student corrects the thesis and that it appropriately reflects the examiners' suggestions for revisions prior to re-submission of the thesis.
The candidate will normally revise and re-submit the thesis for re-assessment, usually by the same examiner. If/when review of the revised thesis is required, the Thesis Unit will contact the initial examiner to determine their availability. In rare cases, a revised thesis may be sent to a new examiner if the first examiner is not available to re-examine the thesis. For more, please see Thesis examination failures.
If the revised thesis is again ‘not passed’, the student will be withdrawn from the University unless the decision is reversed through an appeal to the Hearing Committee (Bias, Error, or Misrepresentation ).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial 4.0 International License . Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies, McGill University .
Department and University Information
Graduate and postdoctoral studies.
404 Not found
Dr Rajasekaran
Professor of English
Motivational & Conference Speaker/YouTuber
Ph. D/M.Phil Thesis Evaluation/Viva-Voce Conducted
Ph.D. Viva Voce Conducted (16 )
External Examiner for PhD viva voce of Mr Sankar of Sri Vijay Vidhyalaya College of Arts and Science, Dharmapuri thesis submitted to Periyar University, Salem held on 20.11.23. Thesis title: “Colonial Incarceration: Post Colonialism and Magic Realism in Ben Okri’s The Famished Road Series”.
External Examiner for PhD viva voce of Ms N Saranya of Kongunadu College of Arts and Science, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore held on 13.10.23. Thesis title: “Travel: A Beacon of Futurity in the Select Novels of Amitav Ghosh”.
External Examiner for PhD viva voce of Mr Athisayaraj of Kongunadu College of Arts and Science, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore held on 25.08.23. Thesis title: “A Kaleidoscopic View of Gender Issues in the Select Novels of Jane Austen”.
External Examiner for PhD viva voce of Ms D Ramya of Government Arts and Science College, Komarapalayam. Thesis submitted to Periyar University, Salem held on 13.06.23. Thesis title: “A Study on The Use of Information Communication Technology (ICT) Tools To Improve The Communicative Competence of Undergraduate Students of Select Engineering Colleges In Erode District”.
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms Suhana P A of Sri Narayana Guru College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore held on 25.4.2023. Thesis title : ‘Memory, Politics and Transnationalism in the Works of Mohsin Hamid and Kamila Shamsie’
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Mrs. Leela Davidson of Voorhees College, Vellore thesis submitted to Thiruvalluvar University, Vellore held on March 29, 2023. Thesis title “Exhilaration and Exasperation: A study of Immigrant Experiences in Jhumpa Lahiri’s Select Works”.
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Mr Roy Xavier of Sri Narayana Guru College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore held on 25.2.2022. Thesis title : ‘‘The Role of Facts and Hopes of Life in the Origin and Existence of Novels in the Light of the Postcolonial Works’
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms C Saffna of Sri Narayana Guru College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore held on 25.2.2022. Thesis title : ‘Diaspora, Memory, Culture Translation, and Culinary Habits in the Selected Fiction of Jhumpa Lahiri’
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms V Vani Ayyaswariya of Tiruppur Kumaran College of Arts and Science for Women thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore held on 24.2.2022. Thesis title : ‘Moirai of Abandonment in The Select Novels of Toni Morrison’
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms P Nisha of Sri Narayana Guru College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore held on 24.2.2022. Thesis title : ‘Challenges and Vulnerabilities of A Misrepresented And Unseen Population: The Transgenders’.
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms P Jagatheeswari of Sri Ramakrishna College of Arts and Science College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, held on 10th January 2023.
Thesis title ‘Surrender to Nature: A Study on the Select Works of Anita Desai and Kiran Desai’
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms K Prabha of National College, Trichy thesis submitted to Bharthidasan University, Trichy held on 19th December 2022.
Thesis Title ‘Asphyxiation of Youth in the Select Novels of Chetan Bhagat’
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms P Nithya of Dr. N.G.P. Arts and Science College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, held on 20th May, 2022.
Thesis title: ‘Resistance from Within: The Saga of Survival and Self-Discovery in Wide Sargasso Sea, Beloved and The God of Small Things’
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Mr C Balamurugan of Kongunadu College of Arts and Science, Coimbatore and the thesis submitted to Bharathiar University held on 6th May 2021.
Thesis Title : Realistic Portrayal Of Indian Society In The Select Plays of Mahesh Dattani – A Study
External Examiner for PhD Viva Voce of Ms P Umadevi of Kogunadu College of Arts and Science, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore.
Thesis title ‘Effectiveness of Mixed Method Listening Strategies in Enhancing Listening Skills among the Under Graduate Students of Coimbatore District A Study’ July 2020
Conducted Public Viva Voce exam at National College Trichy to S Mathivanan for his PhD Thesis Titled ‘A Study on the Psychological Perspective on the Portrayal of Characters in Select Works of Leo Tolstoy’ submitted to Bharthidasan University, Trichy on 19.9.2017.
P h.D. Thesis Evaluation ( 13 )
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled “Colonial Incarceration: Post Colonialism and Magic Realism in Ben Okri’s The Famished Road Series” by Mr Sankar of Vijay Vidhyalaya College of Arts and Science, Dharmapuri thesis submitted to Periyar University, Salem during September 2023.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘Travel: A Beacon of Futurity in the Select Novels of Amitav Ghosh ’ by Ms Saranya N of Kongunadu College of Arts and Science, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during July 2023.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘A Kaleidoscopic View of Gender Issues in the Select Novels of Jane Austen ’ by Mr Athisayaraj Jebakumar J of Kongunadu College of Arts and Science, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during July 2023.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘Moirai of Abandonment In The Select Novels of Toni Morrison’ by Ms V Vani Ayyaswariya of Tiruppur Kumaran College for Women, Tiruppur thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during October 2022.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘Diaspora, Memory, Culture Translation, and Culinary Habits in the Selected Fiction of Jhumpa Lahiri’ by Ms Safna C of Sri Narayana Guru College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during September 2022.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘The Role of Facts and Hopes of Life in the Origin and Existence of Novels in the Light of the Postcolonial Works: The Bluest Eye, The God of Small Things, The Inheritance of Loss, and Americanah’ by Mr Roy Xavier of Sri Narayana Guru College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during September 2022.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘Challenges and Vulnerabilities of A Misrepresented And Unseen Population: The Transgenders’ by Ms P Nisha of Sri Narayana Guru College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during September 2022.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘Surrender to Nature: A Study on the Select Works of Anita Desai and Kiran Desai by Ms P Jagatheeswari of Sri Ramakrishna College of Arts and Science College, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during June 2022.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘A Study on the Use of Information Communication Technology (ICT) Tools to Improve the Communicative Competence of Undergraduate Students of Select Engineering Colleges’ by Ms D Ramya Government Arts and Science College, Komarapalayam thesis submitted to Periyar University, Salem during January 2022.
Adjudicated PhD thesis titled ‘Realistic Portrayal Of Indian Society In The Select Plays of Mahesh Dattani – A Study’ by Mr C Balamurugan of Kongunadu College of Arts and Science, Coimbatore thesis submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore during November 2020.
Thesis Title : Realistic Portrayal Of Indian Society In The Select Plays Of Mahesh Dattani – A Study
Adjudicated Ph D thesis titled ‘Understanding Others : A study of Dalit Women Writes in Bakhtinian Light’ submitted to Gujarat University, Ahmedabad by Ms Vaishnavi Upadhay during January 2020.
Adjudicated Ph D thesis titled ‘Effectiveness of Mixed Method Listening Strategies in Enhancing Listening Skills Among the Under Graduate Students of Coimbatore District: A Study’ submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore by Ms P Umadevi during December 2019.
Adjudicated Ph D thesis titled ‘Shashi Desphande and Ruth Prawer Jhabvala : A Comparative Study’ submitted to Manonmaniyam Sundaranar University, Tirunelveli by Mr Edward Singh M during June 2018.
M.Phil. Thesis Evaluation (5)
Evaluated M.Phil thesis titled ‘‘The Ecocritical Reading of Sobhaa De’s works’ submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore by Mr Benjamin A during July 2023.
Evaluated M.Phil thesis titled ‘‘The Effect of Monetary Urge over Human Relationships in Sobhaa De’s Sisters and Socialite Evenings’ submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore by Ms Mahima Loretta A during January 2020.
Evaluated M.Phil thesis titled ‘‘Theme of Resistance in the Select Works of Nayantara Sahghal’ submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore by Mr Robin Renottson L during January 2020.
Evaluated M.Phil thesis titled ‘A Psychoanalytic Study on Homicidal Anthropophagist : A Real Life Serial Killer in John Borowski’s Albert Fish: In His Own Words’ submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore by Ms Joy Hepzibah C during November 2019.
Evaluated M.Phil thesis titled ‘Portrayal of Society and Culture in the select novels of Amitav Ghosh’ submitted to Bharathiar University, Coimbatore by Ms Malini R during November 2018.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
abstract. Traditionally, examiners 'reports on theses at the doctoral and Masters level consist of two. components: firstly, summative assessment where a judgement is made about whether. the ...
The thesis merits the award of MS/MPhil degree after minor changes as suggested. The thesis merits the award of MS/MPhil degree after major revision as suggested. Please Tick (√) the appropriate, if major changes required: a) The document is supposed to be sent back for re-evaluation after incorporating the major changes
Abstract and Figures. Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment for the award an MPhil Degree at the University of Ghana. Group Lending Approaches. Conceptual Framework. Educational Levels of ...
This is a template to guide students and beginners writing their abstracts for their thesis and research papers. PDF | This is a sample of an M. Sc. preliminary evaluation report. The report gives ...
A doctoral thesis is the culmination of three years full time work. By definition, it should be publishable in whole or in part. This means that the candidate has mastered the thesis genre, has written an original evaluation of the relevant literature, innovatively collected and analysed data, and presented the work in
For M.Phil and Ph.D. theses, Examiners may recommend the award of such degrees with "High Commendation"; (v) For M.Phil theses of exceptional standard and potential for further work, Examiners may recommend the transfer of the candidates' registration to the Ph.D. degree. 2.
In particular, the evaluation should address the scholarly quality of the presentation (e.g. engagement with relevant literature, methodology and/or data) and the format of the presentation (verbal communication and quality of any visual illustrations such as PowerPoint slides). This written evaluation can then be included in the progress review
Pakistan Research Repository is a digital archive of theses and dissertations produced by scholars from the higher education institutions of Pakistan. It provides free access to the full text of research papers, as well as information about the authors, supervisors, reviewers, and journals. It also facilitates the verification of PhD degrees by the HEC.
Highlights. We examine the connection between feedback and assessment in examiners' reports. We suggest the crucial role of feedback in postgraduate thesis examination practice. Feedback will close the gap between the candidate's current and desired performance. Emphasis on feedback affects examiners, the university, supervisors and candidates.
University of Bern defines the following six standards for Doctoral thesis evaluation reports: 1. Evaluate the thesis independently. Do not refer to other evaluations of the same thesis. 2. Evaluate the content but not the form at of the thesis. 3. Evaluate the content of the thesis but not the Doctoral student as a person. 4. Provide a short ...
C. MINOR COMPONENTS OF THE THESIS (BACK MATTERS) 21 Bibliography or References or Works or Literature Cited 21 D. PUBLISHING FROM THESIS, AUTHORSHIP PROTOCOLS AND GUIDES 24 E. EVALUATION OF HIGHER DEGREE RESEARCH THESIS 26 F. GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS 27 G. OTHER CONSIDERATIONS 28 H. APPENDICES 31 Evaluation of MPhil Thesis 42
It is certified that this thesis titled, "Title of Thesis", submitted by _____, Registration No. _____, for MS/M.Phil. degree at "Faculty Name", University of Central Punjab, is an original research work and contains satisfactory material to be eligible for evaluation by the Examiner(s) for the award of the above stated degree.
° « e m w £ á Ò f § 6KUHH 6RPQDWK 6DQVNULW 8QLYHUVLW\ ~ § ` ¤ ¡ y E f § Ä Ç Ã Ã Ç Ç y « ~ y ¡ ~
the PhD thesis and determines often the success or failure of the whole PhD project. In the introductory part of this evaluation, I commended author´s choice of the topic. Unfortunately, I consider the definition of the goals and the scope of the thesis rather vague. I admit that the scope
The thesis supervisor submits a written statement on the thesis with a proposal for a grade, i.e. an evaluation statement to the Degree Programme Committee. When preparing the report, the supervisor may also request statements from the advisor(s). In cases where the supervisor has proposed the grade '5' or '1' or 'fail', the Degree ...
Examiners are asked to evaluate the thesis in myThesis, according to the criteria in the respective thesis examiner report for a Master's or Doctoral thesis. For an example of the criteria, please see the forms: see: Master's Examiner report form; Doctoral Examiner report form (note these forms are now integrated in myThesis). Examiners provide an overall judgment of 'passed' or 'not passed ...
Appendix A2 MS MPhil Research Progress Review Form. Appendix A3 MS MPhil Thesis Evaluation Form. Appendix B1 PhD Supervisory Agreement Form. Appendix B2 PhD Progress Report Form (Semester Wise) Appendix B3 Application for an Extension to Final Thesis Submission. Appendix B4 Progress Report of Time Barred Students and Request for Extension.
2. NUMBER OF PERMANENT RELEVANT M.PHIL. / MS. FACULTY Nam e of Facu lty Degree M.Phil./MS Title of M.Phil. /MS Degree Date of M.Phil./ MS. Comple tion Post M.Phil. /MS degree Exp. (in years) Date of Joining Number of relevant publicat ions Subj ect specializ ation With/wit hout thesis HEC Attested / Equival ency in P U In any other univ/ post ...
sheets/evaluation reports and details of foreign evaluators relevant to his/her department to ARC 5.11 Propose Internal Examiners for PhD/MS/MPhil Proposal Defense to ARC for approval 5.12 Propose External Examiners for PhD/MS/MPhil Thesis Defense to ARC for approval 5.13 Organize research proposal/theses defense through ARC
Form for Evaluation of MPhil, PhD Theses - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Graduate Study & Research should correspond to (a) the number of thesis need to be submitted is 4 (including thesis of supervisors) for an M.Tech/MPhil./MSc Degree student, and (b) the number of thesis to be submitted for a Ph.D. degree student are 5 copies (for single supervisor) and 6 copies (for co-supervisor).
Appendix C5 PhD Thesis Evaluation Form (for External Examiners) Appendix C6 PHD Thesis Summary of Changes Form ; Appendix C7 Final Pre-defense Clearance create; Appendix C8 Checklist for PhD Thesis Defense; Schedule C9 PhD Degree Defense Form (for Local Examiners) Annex C10 Rubric fork Evaluating PhD Thesis Defense; Ph.D. Synopsis/Thesis Formatting
Ph. D/M.Phil Thesis Evaluation | Drvraj